Which of the following is one of the major criticism of the humanistic approach to personality?

Do you believe that people are basically good? Do you believe that every person wants to grow into their best self? Maybe you believe that with the right environment and support, every person can become their best self and a good person. If so, humanistic theories of personality might appeal to you.

  • What is the humanistic theory in psychology?
  • What is the humanistic definition of personality?
  • What is Maslow's humanistic approach to personality?
  • What is the humanistic theory of personality by Carl Rogers?
  • What are some examples of humanistic theories of personality?

Humanistic Theory in Psychology

Alfred Adler is considered to be the founding father of individual psychology. He was also one of the first psychological theorists to claim that the birth order in your family directly influences your personality. Adler thought that most humans have just one main goal: to feel important and like they belong.

Humanistic psychologists find that the way a person chooses to behave is directly influenced by their self-concept and their environment.

Humanistic psychologists consider how a person's environment, including past experiences, has shaped the person into who they are now and guided them to make certain choices.

Humanistic psychology is made up of five core principles:

  1. Human beings supersede the sum of their parts.

  2. Each human is unique.

  3. Human beings are aware and conscious beings with the capacity for self-awareness.

  4. Human beings have free will, can make their own choices, and are responsible for their own choices.

  5. Human beings intentionally work to achieve future goals. They also seek meaning, creativity, and value in life.

The humanistic theory focuses on a person’s motivation and desire to be good and do good. The humanistic theory of personality also focuses on free will or the ability to choose personal outcomes.

Humanistic Definition of Personality

The humanistic theory of personalityassumes that people are basically good and want to become their best selves. This goodness and motivation for self-improvement is innate and pushes each person to reach their potential. If a person is held back from this goal, it is due to their environment and not internal causes.

The humanistic theory focuses on a person’s tendency to choose good behaviors. The theory is formed around the belief that people want to achieve self-actualization and can do that with the right environment and help around them. The humanistic theory of personality focuses on the uniqueness of each person and their efforts to be good and achieve self-actualization.

Maslow's Humanistic Approach to Personality

Abraham Maslow is an American psychologist who believed that people possess free will and self-determination: the ability to make decisions and shape their own life. Maslow believed that you can choose to become whoever you want to be and you can achieve self-actualization.

Self-actualization is the ability to reach your full potential and be the best version of yourself. Self-actualization is at the top of the pyramid and the final goal in Maslow’s hierarchy of needs.

Which of the following is one of the major criticism of the humanistic approach to personality?
Fg. 1 Self-actualization! pixabay.com.

A distinctive aspect of Maslow's theory that sets him apart from others is those on whom he chose to study and base his theories. While many theorists and psychologists choose to formulate their ideas by investigating unique, clinically diagnosed people, Maslow chose to examine people who were successful, and sometimes even well-known, who he claimed all had similar traits. He believed these people had achieved self-actualization.

One such famous person he studied was none other than the 16th president of the United States, Abraham Lincoln. Based on Maslow's investigation of Lincoln and others' personalities, he made his assertation that these people were all focused on being self-aware and empathetic, and did not focus on other people's judgment of them. He said they focused more on a problem at hand than themselves and often concerned themselves with one main focus throughout their lives.

Humanistic Theory of Personality by Carl Rogers

Carl Rogers is an American psychologist that believed that humans had the ability to change and grow into better people. Rogers believed that a person needed an environment that had empathy and genuineness so that they could become a good person. Rogers believed that it was not possible for a human to learn how to have healthy relationships and be healthy without this environment.

Carl Rogers believed that there are three parts to your beliefs about yourself (your self-concept):

  1. Self-Worth

  2. Self-Image

  3. Ideal Self

Carl Rogers believed that these three components need to be congruent and overlap with each other in order to achieve self-actualization.

Which of the following is one of the major criticism of the humanistic approach to personality?
Fg. 2 All three components contribute to self-concept. StudySmarter original.

Rogers believed that in order for you to attain your goals and live a good life, you need to hold to certain life principles. He found that people who were functioning at their fullest potential had these principles in common. Rogers also said that the process of living a good life is constantly changing, which means that every person can start now to change the future.

Principles of a Good Life:

  1. Being open to experience.

  2. An existential lifestyle.

  3. Trusting oneself.

  4. Freedom of choice.

  5. Being creative and able to adapt easily.

  6. Reliability and constructiveness.

  7. Live a rich, full life.

These are not easy to achieve. Rogers explained it best in his book On Becoming a Person:

This process of the good life is not, I am convinced, a life for the faint-hearted. It involves the stretching and growing of becoming more and more of one’s potentialities. It involves the courage to be. It means launching oneself fully into the stream of life.” (Rogers, 1995)

Examples of Humanistic Theories of Personality

How do you think the humanistic theory of personality would view someone robbing a bank? It states that humans are inherently good and make good choices, but can be held back from their potential due to their environment.

Following this logic, the humanistic theory of personality would say that a robber is still a good person, but that environment caused them to act in this way. In this instance, the environment would be monetary problems that forced the robber to go to these lengths.

On the flip side, the humanistic theory of personality states that you are in control of your own actions and are able to grow to your full potential. An example of this would be job promotions at work. Through your hard work, you get a professional promotion. With each promotion you get, you are realizing your potential and working hard to achieve it.

Humanistic Theories of Personality - Key takeaways

  • Carl Rogers is an American psychologist that believed that humans had the ability to change and grow into better people.

  • Abraham Maslow is an American psychologist that believed that people have free will and the ability of self-determination.

  • Alfred Adler is considered to be the founding father of individual psychology.

  • The humanistic theory focuses on a person’s tendency to do good and choose good behaviors. It is formed around the belief that people want to achieve self-actualization and can do that with the right environment and help around them.

  • Components of Self Concept: self-worth, self-image, and ideal self.


References

  1. Rogers, C. (1995). On becoming a person: A therapist’s view of psychotherapy (2nd ed.). HarperOne.

What is a major criticism of the humanistic approach to personality?

One major criticism of humanistic psychology is that its concepts are too vague. Critics argue that subjective ideas such as authentic and real experiences are difficult to objectify; an experience that is real for one individual may not be real for another person.

What are 3 criticisms of the humanistic perspective?

A) Its concepts are vague and subjective. B) The emphasis on the self encourages selfishness in individuals. C) Humanism fails to appreciate the reality of evil in human behavior. D) All of these are common criticisms.

What is a common criticism of humanistic theories of personality quizlet?

What are the major criticisms of humanistic theories of personality? Critics of the humanistic approach argue that these theories are based on naive assumptions and are not scientifically testable or well supported by empirical evidence. Their focus on description, rather than explanation, makes them narrow.

Which of the following is a critique of the humanistic approach quizlet?

Which of the following is a critique of the humanistic approach? The theory is too optimistic about human nature. In keeping with the social cognitive emphasis on the person's cognitive abilities and mental states.